Comments

Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.

Viewing most recent comments 43 to 47 of 47 · Previous page · First page
(+1)

Great music, great aesthetic, enjoyable characters. I understand some people feeling the VHS look is a bit straining although it didn't personally bother me. I'd love to see a full game come of this!

Glad to hear you enjoyed it! Stay tuned for more, and if you're interested I post updates and screenshots on twitter and instagram!

(+4)

Hey, great game! even though i only managed to get 3/4 endings (if the checking on todd thing even counts as one, that is)
Uuh, my pronouns seemed to change halfway through the game, and the VHS-ish filter is a bit of an eyesore, a way to tone it down or turn it off would be really great djasijasidjas

Still a really fun game, looking forward to the full release.

ALSO if you ever need translations done for the game I'd be happy to help with a portuguese adaptation

(1 edit) (+3)(-1)
hello, I played your game twice because I took a "Game Over" going to see Todd (I'm a person worried about friends) and on the second I did the ending with Rose, because it is very clear that she has feelings for the MC and it’s kind of hard to reject it. The characters presented are very interesting and resemble people that we have in our cycle of friends, even though Todd, Anne and Sarah did not show up, they made me curious to have more of them and I will look forward to the launch of the game, the only criticism I have is that the pronouns are leaving in some places in the wrong way, but other than that, excellent work, success <3 (forgiveness for mistakes, I'm Brazilian with English level still far from ideal)
(1 edit) (+2)

Idk man... so far they reeeaaally seem to like me. :P


I've gotten 4 endings. Unless there's some super secrets, I doubt I missed anything.

The game has a very interesting 90s aesthetic. I feel it could be even more apparent with color (for example, if Rose's outfit were yellow like Alicia Silverstein's Clueless get-up), but I'm trusting that the black&white sprites were a conscious decision -- especially since the two ending CGs were in color. 

The characters.... grew on me, but it took a bit of time. Maria seemed a bit inconsistent, playfully teasing me about canoodling with Rose one moment, and then being pissed the next moment I choose to stay with Rose. And then apologizing for being angry, saying she totally understands why I would choose Rose. ???Que???

Perhaps this is because it's the playthrough where I tried to be a good friend and hang out with them equally. I understand Maria has mixed feelings, but still, maybe that could have been shown a bit more through dialogue.

There's a Very Special Moment after the Campfire Drama happens, if I side with Maria, go talk to Rose, and uh... still side with Maria? I reminded me of another game that I won't name, and I couldn't help wondering if the game would take a darker turn. But so far, that was the only Special Moment I found.

Transitions for both sprites and music are a bit abrupt. I'd recommend trying out something like "with dissolve" and "fadein 1.5" respectively. Especially when the static overlay of disapproval starts -- it'd be good to still have a little music fading out.

There's a very nice narrative touch when Maria goes quiet if you choose to bitch about your parents.

One complaint: when searching for the matches, I wanted to stay at camp by myself. Rose could just go with Maria... It seemed like a good compromise to me! lol. But when I elected to stay at camp, the narration unfortunately assumed I was choosing Rose.  :(


Some playtesting notes:

Since I played as a girl, there were a could of missed gender-cues.

Maria "Her not-boyfriend just took some other girl's side in an argument." (And then the next two subsequent lines. Boyfriend boyfriend boyfriend lol.)

Also: "Like, in high school, you didn't want to be the kid who talked about his parents."

And a couple typos:

"Afraid I'll peak?"  Should be "peek" I think lol.

Maria "Well, okay Rose, two option here." Should be two options.


This was all I could find; at the beginning I was too busy trying to get a feel for the game and didn't let myself get distracted my any minor errors. About halfway through though, I was pretty confident that nothing was out to get me in the dark woods, and was comfortable jotting down some notes.


Overall, I had enough fun that I would be down to see these characters again. Had a bit of an iffy experience naming myself "Mia," though, since we sounded like triplets born to confuse people lmao. Maria, Mia, and Rose.... It's like a tongue twister.

When the next DTIPIJDLY comes out I'll definitely be named something else. :)

(+1)

Thanks for the feedback, especially the playtesting notes! I don't know how the pronouns slipped through there, I'll be sure to catch those in this weekends update. 

I'll also say that you've caught the only Very Special Scene... for now. And that you don't have to worry too much about it being like a certain unnamed game.  The knives aren't coming out anytime soon, and you'll need to worry about a lot more than JUST ROSE.

(+1)

I saw this posted on reddit! Just the writing on this download page reads pretty well. I'll give this a download and leave a follow-up comment when I'm done playing. :)

Viewing most recent comments 43 to 47 of 47 · Previous page · First page